Yes, you can learn a lot of guitar by yourself. Many good players started with books, videos, tabs and stubborn curiosity. The risk is not that self-teaching cannot work. The risk is that you may practise the wrong thing for weeks without realising it.
A private guitar teacher is not magic. You still have to practise. What a good teacher gives you is feedback, order and a calmer route through all the noise online.
Self-teaching works best for simple, visible jobs: tuning the guitar, learning a few open chords, copying a strumming pattern, or following a beginner song tutorial. If you are patient and choose sensible material, you can make a decent start.
The common problems are small but stubborn. A thumb sits in the wrong place. A finger presses too far from the fret. The strumming hand tenses up. The student thinks they cannot play a chord, when the real issue is one angle of one finger.
Those details are hard to spot from your own viewpoint. They are also hard to fix from a generic video, because the video cannot see what you are doing.
There is more free guitar information available than any beginner could ever use. That sounds helpful, but it can become a problem. One video says learn scales. Another says learn songs. Another says theory. Another says fingerstyle.
A good starting path is simpler: tune the guitar, learn a few comfortable chord shapes, build a steady strum, and apply those skills to songs you actually like. The article on what a beginner should learn first on guitar goes into that order in more detail.
Lessons are useful when the same problem keeps coming back. If your chords stay muted, your rhythm falls apart, or you are losing motivation because practice feels random, a teacher can usually diagnose the problem quickly.
This does not mean you need lessons forever. Some beginners take weekly lessons at the start, then move to occasional check-ins. Others prefer steady support because it keeps them practising. If you are weighing up lessons against free online material, one-to-one guitar lessons vs YouTube may help you decide.
Give yourself a short plan for the next four weeks. Keep it boring enough to work. Ten minutes of focused chord changes will help more than an hour spent scrolling for the perfect tutorial. If you need a simple structure, the beginner guitar practice routine article is a useful place to start.
If you have tried carefully and the guitar still feels physically awkward, ask for help sooner rather than later. Sore fingers are normal at first. Sharp pain, constant buzzing, or feeling completely lost are signs that something needs adjusting.
The goal is not to prove you can do everything alone. The goal is to keep enjoying the guitar and make steady progress. Sometimes one lesson can remove a blockage that has been annoying you for months.
You can learn guitar by yourself, but you do not have to turn it into a test of willpower. Use online material carefully, keep your practice simple, and get feedback when a problem refuses to shift.
If you are learning on your own and want a clear plan, book a guitar lesson and I can help you tidy up the basics without starting again.
If you've enjoyed this article, please share it!

Save time and learn faster with Mike. If you are based in Leeds, then I would be happy to help you to become your best at playing guitar.
Learn More